Arkansas Bishop Compares Trump’s America to Nazi Germany

Bishop Anthony Taylor’s powerful statement adds fuel to the growing moral uprising from U.S. Catholic leaders against Trump-Vance’s MAGA authoritarianism.

Thank you for reading! Letters from Leo is a reader-supported publication. If you find value in my work, please consider becoming a paid subscriber or making a one-time donation.

In an extraordinary message this week, Bishop Anthony B. Taylor of Little Rock warned that history may be in danger of repeating itself.

In a Jan. 24 column for his diocesan newspaper, Taylor wrote that “polarization and partisanship are poisoning the social fabric of our country,” creating a moral decline disturbingly reminiscent of 1930s Germany.

The Arkansas bishop — whose own grandfather lost 20 cousins in the Holocaust – was careful to stress that “the current times are not identical” Yet he argued that America faces “many obvious parallels with the 1930s” in a society moving “away from respect for human dignity, peace and moral restraint.”

Unless Americans remember the lessons of that dark era, Taylor warned, “we are doomed to repeat failures of the past”.

In his statement, Bishop Taylor painted an unnerving portrait of those historical parallels.

He recalled how a young German democracy with weak checks and balances succumbed to an eloquent demagogue who exploited fear and economic crisis.

Adolf Hitler’s rise saw political opponents silenced by intimidation or imprisonment, and an embittered populace enthralled by talk of a superior “real” German people scapegoating those deemed outsiders.

As critical thought and civility evaporated, German society slid into brutality. Taylor fears a similar dynamic is unfolding in the United States “with the decline of civil discourse” and the poisoning effect of extreme partisanship.

The bishop drew especially sharp comparisons on the treatment of migrants. He recounted the tragedy of Jewish refugees aboard the MS St. Louis in 1939, turned away by multiple countries — including the United States — and ultimately sent back to their deaths.

“Obviously, these tragic examples are not what is happening here today,” Taylor acknowledged. “But these are the kinds of atrocities to which the dehumanization of mass, indiscriminate deportation can naturally lead.”

He noted the “sad chapters” in U.S. history, from the Trail of Tears to the internment of Japanese Americans, as reminders of how easily a nation can betray its ideals through fear and exclusion.

Today, he argued, U.S. borders remain largely closed to those in desperate need, and recent policies even cut off life-saving foreign aid — choices that will only increase suffering and migration pressures. Caring for refugees and the poor, Taylor insisted, “is a pro-life issue” that tests the nation’s conscience.

Bishop Taylor’s plea comes amid an escalating moral confrontation between the Catholic Church and President Donald Trump.

Pope Leo XIV, the first U.S.-born pontiff, has repeatedly voiced alarm at the resurgence of nativism and militarism. Politico notes that the Chicago-born pope and Trump “are on a collision course,” with migration emerging as “the main combat zone” between Leo’s social vision and the White House agenda.

Following Leo’s lead, a growing number of U.S. bishops are openly challenging what they see as a dangerous erosion of American ideals.

Their warnings have grown especially urgent after recent events, such as the fatal shooting of two civilians during ICE deportation raids in Minneapolis — incidents church leaders called a “profound moral failure” and “a national disgrace”.

Around the country, prelates are raising their voices in unison.

“The country cannot go on like this,” wrote Los Angeles Archbishop José Gomez, decrying a climate that treats migrants “as if they have no rights. That should not be happening.”

In Washington, Cardinal Robert McElroy and an interfaith coalition denounced the “normalization of dehumanization” in Trump’s crackdown, vowing, “We will not accept the tearing apart of our neighborhoods.” Bishop Taylor’s voice has now joined this choir of conscience.

In closing his statement, Taylor implored Americans to reclaim a spirit of civil dialogue and compassion before it is too late. He urged every Catholic to read Pope Leo’s January 9 address to Vatican diplomats — a speech that framed today’s challenges through the lens of St. Augustine’s City of God.

Pope Leo himself used that occasion to warn of “grave dangers to political life” arising from “false representations of history, excessive nationalism and the distortion of the ideal of the political leader.”

The pope noted that “war is back in vogue” and that peace is now often pursued “through weapons and asserting one’s own dominion,” a mentality that “gravely threatens the rule of law” underpinning civilized society.

Bishop Taylor echoed that concern and urged his flock not to lose hope or grow numb. Even if ordinary people feel powerless, he reminded us that complacency is exactly what enabled evil to flourish in the 1930s.

Instead, he calls on citizens, like Pope Leo XIV, to stand up, speak out, and recognize “the stranger in our midst” not as an enemy, but as a brother or sister made in God’s image.

At a moment of mounting tension, his message is a clarion call to moral courage — and a stark warning that the cost of silence may be the repetition of a history we once swore never to forget.

Letters from Leo is ready to speak out on behalf of the dignity of God’s children. Deal us in. Rooted in a faith that demands justice and refuses to bow to godless MAGA authoritarianism, we are the fastest-growing Catholic community in the United States.

We’re open to anyone who wants to be informed and inspired by our pope — and who is ready to turn that inspiration into action that makes America and the world more just, less cruel, and more alive with hope.

If you’d like to invest in our mission during this new year, here are three ways you can help:

• Subscribe as a paid member to receive exclusive posts about the life and formation of Pope Leo and help sustain this newsletter.

• Donate with a one-time gift to fuel this project’s mission.

• Share this post (and Letters from Leo) with a friend who might enjoy it.

Paid subscribers will also have access to our Sunday Reflection Series and the Q&A mailbag that opened last week, where you can ask me anything about American politics, Catholicism, Donald Trump, Pope Leo, JD Vance — or my own faith, biography, and life.

Whether you give $0, $1, or $1,000, your presence here matters — no matter your faith or your politics.

Thank you for reading. I’ll see you on the road.