Fourth Rebuke in Eight Days: Pope Leo Intensifies Clash with Trump Over Migrants

In his latest rebuke of Trumpism, Pope Leo praises immigrants as “agents of hope” and tells Catholics their faith is tested by how they welcome the stranger.

Pope Leo XIV isn’t letting up.

For the fourth time in eight days, the new pontiff has directly challenged President Donald Trump’s treatment of migrants — an unprecedented flurry of papal critique that has escalated tensions with the MAGA movement.

The latest broadside came in a letter Pope Leo sent to Catholic Charities USA’s 115th Annual Meeting this week, where he hailed immigrants as “witnesses to hope” and praised those who welcome them.

The pope commended Catholic Charities’ 168 agencies as “agents of hope” for the vulnerable, saying their outreach “makes the Lord’s providence concrete” for families forced to rely on others.

He urged communities to continue helping new arrivals be “living witnesses of hope, recognizing that they have an intrinsic human dignity and are invited to participate fully in community life.”

Migrants, he noted, often strengthen society through their resilience and “vibrant faith” — a pointed rejoinder to those who would treat them as threats rather than brothers and sisters.

This comes at a time when the Trump Administration has been trying to defund the venerable organization for the past nine months.

This letter marks Pope Leo’s fourth high-profile critique of Trump-aligned immigration policies in just over a week.

It began on Sept. 30, when Leo stunned observers by declaring that “someone who says, ‘I’m against abortion, but I’m in agreement with the inhuman treatment of immigrants,’ I don’t know if that’s pro-life.”

Coming from the first American-born pope, that remark — effectively accusing Trump’s anti-immigrant Catholic allies of hypocrisy — sent shockwaves through political circles.

Five days later, on Sunday, Oct. 5, Leo devoted his homily to the dignity of migrants and refugees, lamenting “the tragedy” faced by families fleeing violence and warning that boats filled with desperate people “must not find the coldness of indifference or the stigma of discrimination” from Christians.

“No one should be forced to flee. Human dignity must always come first,” the pope insisted that day.

Then on Oct. 8, Pope Leo held a private audience with U.S. immigrant advocates and border bishops, where he became visibly emotional hearing letters from migrant families.

He denounced the Trump administration’s renewed deportation blitz as an injustice, telling the group that “the Church cannot stay silent before injustice. You stand with me, and I stand with you.”

Leo urged the entire U.S. bishops’ conference to speak out more forcefully against harsh immigration crackdowns, effectively encouraging Catholic leaders to take a harder line against Trump’s record.

Bishop Mark Seitz of El Paso, who helped organize the meeting, said the pope “was so moved” and reaffirmed that he would continue to raise his voice in defense of immigrant families.

In Letters from Leo’s own reporting on this meeting, I noted that two popes — Leo and his predecessor Francis — have now castigated Trump’s immigration agenda over the past year.

This rapid barrage of papal intervention underscores just how sharply Leo has drawn the battle lines.

Each of these papal actions openly challenges policies emblematic of Trump’s “America First” platform.

The result is that the conflict between the Vatican and America’s Trumpist nationalist camp has burst into the open.

Trump’s allies have responded in kind — some condemning Leo as a “woke Marxist heretic” for his social justice stance — further highlighting the rift between a pope championing a Gospel of welcome and a political movement rooted in fear and exclusion.

At its heart, this moment represents a broader global moral confrontation.

It’s not just Pope Leo vs. Donald Trump; it’s the Christian ethic of welcome versus the politics of fear.

Leo’s messages echo a consistent biblical refrain: “Do not oppress the stranger; you yourselves know how it feels to be foreigners” (cf. Exodus 23:9).

He is essentially telling millions of Catholics that protecting immigrant children and families is as pro-life as protecting the unborn — an idea that profoundly unsettles a U.S. religious right accustomed to equating “pro-life” with a single issue.

As he noted in his apostolic exhortation Dilexi te (“I Have Loved You”) released today, the stakes transcend partisan politics.

Will the Church’s ancient mandate to “welcome the stranger” triumph over modern campaigns to wall out the vulnerable?

Pope Leo is betting the soul of his nascent papacy on the answer being yes.

By repeatedly affirming immigrants’ God-given dignity in the face of popular hostility, Leo has cast this clash in stark moral terms: a choice between the “culture of encounter” that he and Pope Francis espouse, and the “culture of walls” that trades on divisiveness and fear.

The coming days will test how American Catholics, and indeed all people of goodwill, respond to this challenge.

One thing is clear: Pope Leo XIV has drawn a line in the sand, and he’s daring the faithful to choose Gospel hope over political fear.

Letters from Leo is open to anyone who wants to be informed and inspired by our pope — and to turn that inspiration into action that leaves America and the world more just, less cold, and more alive with hope.

If you want to support this mission, here’s how you can help:

• Subscribe as a paid member to receive exclusive posts about the life and formation of Pope Leo and help sustain this newsletter.

• Donate with a one-time gift to fuel this project’s mission.

• Share this post (and Letters from Leo) with a friend who might enjoy it.

Whether you give $0, $1, or $1,000, your presence here matters — no matter your faith or your politics.

Thank you for reading. I’ll see you on the road.