In Another Break With Trump, Pope Leo Skips U.S. 250th Celebration for Migrant Island
As Trump builds his presidency around America’s 250th anniversary, the pope heads to Europe’s most symbolic migrant crossing — days after rejecting the president’s “Board of Peace.”
Dear friends —
Beginning this week, Letters from Leo will publish daily Lenten reflections through Easter, available exclusively to paid subscribers.
Each meditation will explore what it means to follow Jesus more faithfully in the midst of American civic and political life — not as partisans first, but as Christians whose consciences are shaped by the Cross.
Lent is a season of repentance, renewal, and resolve.
It is a time to confront our idols, strip away our illusions, and allow the light of God’s redeeming love to search and purify our hearts.
I hope you will walk this forty-day road with me — as your brother and imperfect follower of Jesus — embracing prayer, sacrifice, and deeper conversion, and allowing the God of liberation to claim every corner of our lives and our public witness in an age of creeping authoritarianism.
Letters from Leo is the fastest-growing Catholic community in the country because people are hungry for something deeper than rage and cynicism. They’re looking for courage, for truth, for love made visible in action.
If you’re ready to build a country — and a Church — that is more just, less cruel, and more alive with hope, then you’re already one of us. Let’s walk together.
If you’d like to invest in our mission this Lenten season, here are three ways you can help:
Subscribe as a paid member to receive exclusive posts about the life and formation of Pope Leo and help sustain this newsletter.
Donate with a one-time gift to fuel this project’s mission.
Share this post (and Letters from Leo) with a friend who might enjoy it.
Paid subscribers will have access to our new investigative series on Jeffrey Epstein and Steve Bannon’s attempt to take down Pope Francis.
You’ll also get access to the Q&A mailbag that opened last month, where you can ask me anything about American politics, Catholicism, Donald Trump, Pope Leo, JD Vance — or my own faith, biography, and life.
Whether you give $0, $1, or $1,000, your presence here matters — no matter your faith or your politics.
Thank you for reading. I’ll see you on the road.
Pope Leo XIV will celebrate this coming July 4 not in the United States for its 250th festivities, but on the tiny Italian island of Lampedusa — a migrant gateway in the Mediterranean.
The Vatican announced that on Independence Day the pope will travel to Lampedusa, ground zero of Europe’s migration crisis, instead of attending any U.S. 250th birthday events.
Coming just days after Pope Leo publicly rebuffed President Donald Trump’s invitation to join his “Board of Peace” initiative for Gaza, the decision reads as pointed counter-programming.
Once again, the American-born pontiff is choosing solidarity with the vulnerable over photo-ops with the powerful. “The Vatican will not participate in the Board of Peace for Gaza,” Leo’s Secretary of State flatly stated this week — a diplomatic no to a Trump-led plan many churchmen saw as a cynical, pay-to-play venture imposed on Palestinians.
Now, by opting to spend America’s Independence Day praying with migrants on a remote island, Pope Leo XIV is delivering another message in deeds. It’s not about disrespecting a national holiday — it’s about who and what our celebrations honor.
Competing July 4 Visions
For President Trump, the Fourth of July 2026 is meant to be the triumphant centerpiece of his second term. He has promised “the most spectacular birthday party the world has ever seen” to mark America’s 250th anniversary.
His administration has launched a “Freedom 250” campaign to stage weeks of patriotic spectacle — from a great American state fair on the National Mall to a televised “Patriot Games” sports meet and even a mixed martial arts event at the White House on Flag Day.
The goal, Trump says, is to showcase American greatness and unity on a grand scale.
In that spirit, back in May 2025, JD Vance personally invited Pope Leo to take part in the anniversary celebrations. Many assumed Trump and Vance would welcome the first American pope with open arms during this historic jubilee.
But Pope Leo never accepted the offer.
And on Feb. 8 this year, the Vatican quietly confirmed what was long suspected: the pope has no plans to visit the United States in 2026.
Instead, on the very day of America’s 250th, he will kneel on a rocky outcrop closer to Tunisia than to Washington, bearing witness to those dying in desperate search of freedom.
The contrast could not be sharper. President Trump envisions F-35 flyovers and fireworks in the capital’s sky; Pope Leo will stand under the same sun on Lampedusa, greeting strangers at the door.
Trump wraps himself in the trappings of national glory, while Leo embraces what he calls the “moral obligation” to welcome the migrant and refugee. Their clashing itineraries speak volumes about their clashing values.
It’s not the first time the pope’s schedule has upstaged the president’s pageantry. On June 14, 2025 — Trump’s own birthday — the president reveled in a military parade he’d ordered in Washington, part of his effort to appropriate civic rituals for personal glory.
That same day, Pope Leo XIV appeared only by video in Chicago, yet stole the show in absentia. From the jumbotron at Guaranteed Rate Field, the South Side native delivered an uplifting message of unity and hope to 30,000 hometown faithful attending a Mass in honor of his election.
While the pontiff urged young people to “build community” and put aside “egotistical ways,” protesters in dozens of U.S. cities were in the streets denouncing Trump’s authoritarian theatrics.
In Chicago, a “No Kings” rally downtown drew thousands decrying the very monarchical spectacle unfolding in D.C., where tanks rolled past the Lincoln Memorial.
Even Chicago’s Cardinal Blase Cupich, presiding at the papal celebration, could not avoid a pointed rejoinder to Trumpism: in his homily he reminded the nation that migrants “are here not by invasion, but by invitation” — invited by our own economy and labor needs.
Words of compassion for immigrants met with cheers from the crowd in Chicago, even as fighter jets roared over Washington.
Two very different June 14 scenes; two very different visions of leadership. One leader basked in adulation amidst missiles and flags; the other, though not physically present, inspired hope by elevating the power of service and faith over force.
Small wonder that the phrase “No Kings” has become a rallying cry for those uneasy with Trump’s pomp.
Morality Over Optics
Pope Leo XIV’s refusal to take part in President Trump’s 250th pageant — whether his Board of Peace or his Independence Day extravaganza — is not a snub for snub’s sake.
It is a conscious moral stance.
The 70-year-old pontiff has made clear that true greatness is measured by our treatment of the least among us, not the size of our parades. He has repeatedly condemned what he calls the “inhuman” persecution of immigrant families, aligning the Church firmly against the mass deportations and border cruelty of the Trump era.
He has warned that political leaders cannot claim to defend life while callously demeaning the lives of migrants. And in turning down Trump’s Gaza board, Leo implied that peace built on billion-dollar buy-ins and exclusion of the weak is no peace at all — “Peace is not the mere absence of war. It is a work of justice,” he reminded the world, invoking Pope Paul VI.
Now, by spending July 4 in Lampedusa, he is invoking another prophetic precedent: Pope Francis’s first trip in 2013, when Francis mourned the thousands of refugees drowned at sea and decried a “globalization of indifference” that makes their plight invisible.
Pope Leo will pray on that same island shore, where each shipwreck is a rebuke to the self-satisfied and powerful. In doing so, he pointedly upstages a president who craves the Church’s blessing but not its challenge.
There is little doubt to me that this is intentional counter-programming.
It says: Where Trump builds gilded arches to himself, Leo walks among the exiles. Where the White House throws a party for empire, the U.S.-born Vicar of Jesus Christ opts for penance at the world’s periphery.
Trump may still bask in fireworks on the National Mall this July 4. But the true Independence Day message, Pope Leo suggests, won’t be delivered from a marble podium in Washington — it will rise from a humble Mass on Lampedusa’s rocky soil.
By his presence in that famous migrant passageway, the pope is declaring that the measure of our liberty is how we treat those who yearn for it.
Freedom, in Leo’s eyes, isn’t about triumphant displays of might; it’s about listening to the cry of those who suffer. And on America’s 250th birthday, that cry will be heard — loud and clear — from the shores of Lampedusa.
I think Americans need to remember Pope Leo is the pope of the world not just the U.S. I also think Pope Leo will not come to the U.S. as long as Trump is president.
"There is little doubt to me that this is intentional counter-programming."
Christopher, you are offering an interesting take on Papal Scheduling.
I am just ureally uncomfortable with pushing the Pope vs Trump narrative so strongly. The current administration is so blatantly anti-Gospel values that anything the Pope does, as seen through the lens of that narrative, could be interpreted as directed specifically against Trump. It is that out of control and blatant. We would love him to get into the ring with the Donald.....but.....
....I think this Pope is smarter than that. He stays out of the deep doo-doo of U.S, politics. His decision not to visit the U.S, right away has more to do with cementing his global role than it does to snubbing Trump. His message is clear, consistent and meant to apply globally. And, of course, he is preaching the compassion and mercy and kindness so lacking right now.
I hope the Pope does stay away from us (U.S.) until we have cleared out the debris of what is happening now. He has lit a fire under the U.S. Cardinals and the USCC. He is wisely letting them take the leadership in the more direct action against the inhumanity, cruelty and murder it has let loose on their streets, in their parishes and dioceses and in their neighborhood's detention centers. This is appropriate. They know he has their back but he is smart to let them take the lead. .