JD Vance Twice Tells Pope Leo XIV to Stay Out of American Politics
A stunning reversal for a Republican Party that once raged at JFK for promising to keep his Catholicism out of the White House — eight weeks before Vance publishes a book on his Catholic conversion.
Thank you for reading! Letters from Leo is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support this movement, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
Before you read on: Pope Leo XIV has asked Americans to contact their members of Congress and demand an end to the war in Iran. Answer the pope’s call in one click at standwithpopeleo.com, an app we built to make it as easy as possible.
JD Vance walked onto a Turning Point USA stage in Phoenix this evening, defended the Trump administration’s bombing campaign as a Christian act, and got heckled by his own crowd.
“How can you say that God was never on the side of those who wield the sword,” the vice president asked, mid-defense of American military strikes — and a young man in the audience shouted back the only correct answer a Christian could give: “Jesus doesn’t support genocide.”
The line that followed, delivered minutes later to the same TPUSA crowd, was the one Vance had been workshopping all day.
“There are certainly things the pope has said I disagree with,” the vice president told the room.
Then the kicker: “I think it’s very, very important for the pope to be careful when he talks about matters of theology.”
The journalist Pedro Gonzalez summarized what Vance was actually saying, in fewer words and with more honesty: “Things the pope has said that Vance disagrees with include dropping Tomahawk missiles on seven-to-twelve-year-old girls is bad.”
This follows an appearance on Fox News last night, where he said: “It would be best for the Vatican to stick to matters of morality, to stick to what’s going on with the Catholic Church, and to let the president execute public policy.”
Two attacks in twenty-four hours, on two different stages, aimed at the same target: the moral authority of Pope Leo XIV. The Catholic vice president of the United States, eight weeks before he publishes a book about his conversion to the Catholic faith, has decided to spend a news cycle telling the bishop of Rome to be careful what he says about war.
That posture would have ended a Republican career not that long ago.
In September 1960, John F. Kennedy traveled to Houston and assured a skeptical room of Baptist ministers that he would never take orders from Rome. The speech defined American Catholic political life for two generations.
In 2012, Rick Santorum — then the most prominent Catholic in Republican presidential politics — told George Stephanopoulos that Kennedy’s address “made me want to throw up.”
A Catholic vice president is now asking the pope to do exactly what Kennedy was once celebrated for promising. The reversal is total and deliberate.
What Vance said on Fox News last night and at TPUSA today is also a reversal of what Vance himself was saying just six months ago.
In an October interview, the vice president spoke warmly of the Church’s role in public life, defended the moral authority of the bishops on questions reaching well beyond abortion, and presented his own conversion as a submission to a teaching tradition older and wiser than American politics.
The man who described the Catholic Church as a moral compass for a disoriented nation is the same man who got on Fox News last night to warn the pope to mind his theology, and who walked onto a TPUSA stage today to argue that God smiles on American Tomahawks.
The Church has not changed. Vance’s politics did, the moment Rome refused to bless what this administration is doing.
Vance’s logic, if you can call it that, is selectively applied. The same vice president who attacked President Joe Biden and Speaker Nancy Pelosi for deviating from Catholic teaching on abortion now wants the bishops of Rome silenced when they speak about migrants drowning in the desert and children incinerated by American bombs. MAGA Republicans want the Church’s opinion on abortion, but nothing else.
The timing turns the hypocrisy into farce. In June, Vance plans to publish a book about his conversion to the Catholic faith. He will collect royalties writing about a religion whose living head he just told to shut up about war crimes.
The signings will be held in dioceses whose bishops he treats as foreign agents, and the photographs of him receiving communion will come from priests whose authority traces directly to the Vatican, which he has now declared an unwelcome intruder.
While Vance was working the TPUSA crowd, Donald Trump was making the situation worse from across the Atlantic.
In an interview with an Italian newspaper, the president renewed his attacks on Pope Leo XIV, branding the American-born pontiff a tool of foreign interests and accusing the Holy See of working against the United States.
It was Trump’s fifth attack on the pope in three days, an unbroken streak with no precedent in the modern American presidency — and the choice to deliver this one to an Italian outlet, on the pope’s own continent, was its own kind of provocation.
The reason for the streak is plain enough, though Trump cannot say it out loud. Pope Leo XIV is, at this moment, the most powerful moral voice in the Western world.
He commands an institution older than the United States by 1,750 years, with 1.4 billion adherents and a sovereign state recognized by every major government on earth. He is also American.
That asymmetry is what kills Donald Trump. The presidency cannot fire a pope, indict him, impose tariffs on him, or deport him from the Vatican. Leo’s pulpit reaches every Catholic parish in this nation, and Trump cannot shout it down.
So the president screams, and the vice president provides theological cover. The Fox News appearance was the polite trial balloon. TPUSA was the moment Vance let the message land at full volume before a crowd that came to hear it.
The signal to the MAGA base is that the new conservative orthodoxy permits open hostility toward Rome whenever Rome inconveniences the regime — Cardinal Cupich on immigration, the pope on bombs and borders, and any Catholic leader next who dares to tell the truth about what this administration is doing to the poor.
The most damning critique of the vice president’s evening did not come from a bishop, a Vatican spokesman, or a Democratic senator.
It came from a young man in the TPUSA audience who refused to let Vance dress up American violence as discipleship.
That young heckler — whoever he is — preached a more faithful homily in five words than the vice president of the United States has managed in twenty-four hours of cable hits and stage time. Jesus doesn’t support genocide. Every Catholic in America should write that line down.
The book Vance publishes in June will be marketed as a story of grace and homecoming. It will, in fact, be the public record of a man who professes to have found God in the same Church he is now waging open war against.
The cover tells the same story. Vance chose to photograph a Methodist church — not a Catholic one — for the front of a memoir about becoming Catholic. I think the design choice was deliberate. Vance wants to be president, and anti-Catholicism sits at the core of MAGA identity.
A Methodist steeple softens the Roman problem for the Evangelical primary voters he needs to win in 2028; the pope-bashing of the last forty-eight hours is the same strategy turned up to full volume.
American Catholics — the largest religious bloc in the country — should remember that record at every signing, every interview, and every campaign rally between now and 2028.
At Letters from Leo, we stand with Pope Leo XIV, the bishops who have refused to flinch, and the millions of American Catholics — and countless others of goodwill — who believe the Gospel is not a partisan accessory to be picked up on abortion and dropped on every other question of human dignity.
The hostility this White House is directing at Rome is not a culture-war stunt. It is an attempt to discipline the moral voice of the largest religious community in the world into silence, so that bombs fall, families are deported, and the poor are crushed without anyone in a Roman collar daring to say no.
This is the fastest-growing Catholic community in the country because people are hungry for something deeper than rage and propaganda.
They are looking for courage, for clarity, for a faith that meets the moment instead of fleeing it — and right now, with a Catholic vice president warning the pope about theology one night and getting heckled for defending American bombs the next, that hunger has never been more urgent.
If you believe this movement matters — Catholics and people of goodwill standing for human dignity against an administration that wants the pope silenced — I am asking you to join us.
If you’d like to invest in our mission, here are three ways you can help this Easter season:
Subscribe as a paid member to receive exclusive posts about the life and formation of Pope Leo XIV and help sustain this work.
Donate with a one-time gift to fuel this project’s mission.
Share this post (and Letters from Leo) with a friend who needs to read it.
Paid members get access to our biographical series on Pope Leo’s life and formation, our investigative work on The Epstein-Bannon Investigation, our Scripture Reflection Series, and the best of our full archive of essays.
Whether you give $0, $5, $50, or $5,000, your presence here matters — no matter your faith or your politics.
Thank you for reading. I’ll see you on the road.
Maybe it would be a better idea if JD stayed out of American politics? And why don’t you send the same message to Franklin Graham and his associates from the Evangelical community? Or how about the Secretary of Defense who thinks he’s on a crusade? Pope Leo is not only the Pontiff, but he’s also an American citizen and voter. As such he’s got a right to criticize political leaders.
Vance said the pope needs to be very careful when talking about matters with theology. It used to be that the administration of the U.S. respected the pope. Not anymore.