Pope Leo XIV Called for Peace. MAGA Called Him a Marxist.

After Leo's plea for diplomacy amid Iran strikes, the MAGA Catholic meltdown entered its most revealing chapter yet.

Thank you for reading! Letters from Leo is a reader-supported publication. If you find value in my work, please consider becoming a paid subscriber or making a one-time donation.

On Sunday morning, as American and Israeli bombs fell on Iranian cities, Pope Leo XIV stood in St. Peter’s Square and did what popes do. He called for peace. He pleaded for diplomacy. He warned the world that it stood on the edge of “a tragedy of immense proportions.”

Within hours, the MAGA right erupted.

MAGA personality Mike Cernovich — who once called Pope Leo a “shitlib” and a “far left wing agitator who wants Americans to surrender their guns” — quote-tweeted the pope’s official statement and sneered:

Then came his broadside against Catholic immigration work — a post that racked up 20,000 likes and 3,800 retweets:

Steve Deace, the conservative radio host, took a different tack. He didn’t just attack the pope’s peace plea — he attacked the conclave itself:

That’s right. The reasons for electing Pope Leo XIV are well-known to an evangelical Protestant podcaster in Iowa.

The conspiratorial thinking is no longer fringe. It’s the water table.

Dan Bilzerian, the social media influencer with millions of followers, replied directly to the pope’s @Pontifex account with language too vile to characterize charitably:

Jim Hoft at The Gateway Pundit mocked the pope as sounding like “a grade school girl.”

Conservative social media erupted with the familiar refrain: the pope should stay in his lane.

But here’s the thing. Peace is his lane.

This pushback didn’t begin this weekend. It started the moment white smoke rose over the Sistine Chapel on May 8, 2025. Laura Loomer was first out of the gate. Within minutes of the announcement, she fired off what became an instantly viral post:

Steve Bannon told the Financial Times that “the conclave for the pope was more rigged than the 2020 election.” When asked about the pope potentially interfering with Trump’s mass deportation agenda, Bannon issued a barely veiled threat: “I would stand by.”

Then came October. Pope Leo said that someone who claims to be pro-life but supports “the inhuman treatment of immigrants” is not truly pro-life. Matt Walsh erupted:

Walsh demanded to know whether the pope was saying “God is not pro-life” because the Bible prescribes the death penalty. His fury revealed something deeper than a policy disagreement. It revealed a movement that has made an idol of its own politics — and will not tolerate a pope who refuses to worship at the same altar.

And that is the moral core of what we are witnessing.

The right-wing backlash against Pope Leo XIV is not really about Iran, or immigration, or the death penalty.

It is about authority.

It is about a group of people who spent years claiming the mantle of Catholic orthodoxy — who wrapped themselves in rosaries and Latin Mass aesthetics and pro-life bumper stickers — suddenly discovering that the actual head of their Church disagrees with them.

Not on the fringe issues. On the fundamentals. On war and peace. On the dignity of migrants. On what it means to defend life from the womb to the tomb.

Catholic social teaching has always insisted that peace is not merely the absence of conflict but the presence of justice.

When Pope Leo stood in St. Peter’s Square on Sunday and said that “stability and peace are not built with mutual threats, nor with weapons, which sow destruction, suffering, and death” — he was channeling two thousand years of Church teaching.

He was echoing John XXIII’s Pacem in Terris. He was speaking in the voice of every pontiff who has dared to tell the empires of the world that their bombs do not bring God’s kingdom closer.

The Bannons and Walshes and Loomers and Cernoviches of the world want a pope who blesses their politics. They want a chaplain for American power.

What they got instead is a shepherd — one who smells like his sheep, as Pope Francis used to say — and who will not be bullied into silence by anyone, least of all by a movement that has confused Christian nationalism with Christianity itself.

Let them rage. Let them call him a Marxist. Let them accuse the conclave of being rigged. The pope will keep calling for peace. And the rest of us — Catholic and non-Catholic, left and right, believer and searcher — will keep listening.

Because in a world on fire, the man in white is still the one pointing toward the water.

At Letters from Leo, we stand with the millions of American Catholics — and countless others of goodwill — who believe that peacemaking is not weakness but the deepest form of courage.

In an era poisoned by cruelty and division, we remain rooted in a faith that refuses to flinch before injustice or bow to the idols of fear and authoritarianism.

We’re not just watching history. We’re making it.

This is the fastest-growing Catholic community in the country because people are hungry for something deeper than rage and cynicism. They’re looking for courage, for truth, for love made visible in action — and right now, as the drums of war grow louder and the voices of peace grow scarcer, that hunger has never been more urgent.

If you’re ready to build a country — and a Church — that chooses diplomacy over destruction, dignity over demonization, and the Gospel over the gun, then I’m asking you to join us.

If you’d like to invest in our mission, here are three ways you can help:

• Subscribe as a paid member to receive exclusive posts about the life and formation of Pope Leo and help sustain this newsletter.

• Donate with a one-time gift to fuel this project’s mission.

• Share this post (and Letters from Leo) with a friend who might enjoy it.

Paid subscribers have access to the Lenten Reflection Series and our new investigative series on Jeffrey Epstein and Steve Bannon’s attempt to take down Pope Francis.

You’ll also get access to the Q&A mailbag that opened last month, where you can ask me anything about American politics, Catholicism, Donald Trump, Pope Leo, JD Vance — or my own faith, biography, and life.

Whether you give $0, $1, or $1,000, your presence here matters — no matter your faith or your politics.

Thank you for reading. I’ll see you on the road.