BREAKING: At Pope Leo’s Urging, Bishops Issue Historic Rebuke of Trump’s Raids

Nearly all U.S. Catholic bishops united in Baltimore to denounce the Trump administration’s “inhumane” deportation campaign — a near-unanimous, unprecedented moral stand against a sitting president.

Thank you for reading! Letters from Leo is a reader-supported publication. If you find value in my work, please consider becoming a paid subscriber or making a one-time donation.

America’s Catholic bishops delivered a historic rebuke Wednesday, condemning President Donald Trump’s aggressive immigration raids in a rare, near-unanimous statement.

Meeting at their annual conference in Baltimore, the bishops voted 216-5 (with three abstentions) to approve a “Special Message” on immigration — the first such action in 12 years.

After the overwhelming vote, the assembly of bishops stood and applauded, underscoring the moment’s importance.

Longtime church observers called it perhaps the strongest collective denunciation of a U.S. president by the Catholic hierarchy in American history.

“We oppose the indiscriminate mass deportation of people. We pray for an end to dehumanizing rhetoric and violence, whether directed at immigrants or at law enforcement,” the bishops declared.

Listing a litany of concerns, the prelates described a “climate of fear” among immigrant families — parents afraid to take children to school or even attend church — and deplored the “vilification of immigrants” in public debate.

“We feel compelled now in this environment to raise our voices in defense of God-given human dignity,” the bishops wrote, framing their stance in stark moral terms.

They pledged support for comprehensive immigration reform, insisting that “Human dignity and national security are not in conflict. Both are possible if people of good will work together.”

An Unprecedented United Front

Not since the civil rights era — and never with such unanimity — have American bishops so directly challenged a president’s policies. The last time the bishops issued a special message was in 2013, concerning an Obama administration policy on contraceptive coverage.

This new message, however, is far bolder: a near-unanimous moral condemnation of the government’s treatment of migrants.

“We as Catholic bishops love our country... For this very reason, we feel compelled... to raise our voices in defense of God-given human dignity,” the statement proclaims, in an implicit answer to those who might question the Church’s patriotism. Several bishops noted that this isn’t about politics, but about fundamental Christian ethics.

“This rises above politics and partisanship,” remarked one bishop on the floor, emphasizing that protecting immigrants is not partisan — it’s basic Christianity.

Archbishop Paul S. Coakley of Oklahoma City, the newly elected USCCB president, spoke in strong support of the statement before the vote.

Other prelates across the ideological spectrum — even some typically aligned with Mr. Trump on other issues — praised the message for striking the right balance.

Notably, the conference unanimously approved an amendment making the rebuke even more explicit: at the urging of Cardinal Blase Cupich of Chicago, the bishops inserted a line opposing “indiscriminate deportation” by federal authorities.

“How can we say to people who are suffering that ‘We stand with you’ if we don’t say we oppose the indiscriminate deportation of people?” Cupich argued, prompting nods of agreement around the hall.

The amendment passed immediately, which one bishop said “gave the document gravitas.”

Even bishops who wanted to go further, like San Jose’s Oscar Cantú, admitted the final text was a necessary “strong statement” of moral conviction.

For the handful of dissenters — just five votes against — there was little appetite to mount any public resistance.

“Some wished it were even stronger, others thought it balanced,” one attendee noted, “but in the end virtually everyone knew this had to be done.” The unity on display was itself a powerful statement.

In an era when U.S. bishops have often been divided, here they stood together — progressives and conservatives, cardinals and small-town bishops — declaring that cruelty toward migrants violates the Gospel.

Answering Pope Leo’s Call

Behind this historic moment is the guiding hand of Pope Leo XIV — the first American pope — who has made the plight of migrants a cornerstone of his pontificate. Pope Leo has been even more blunt than the U.S. bishops in condemning

Mr. Trump’s immigration crackdown: just weeks ago, he lambasted the mass raids as “inhuman” and warned that treating migrants like “garbage” is a serious sin.

He also urged the American church to be courageous.

Last month, Bishop Mark J. Seitz of El Paso hand-delivered to Pope Leo a bundle of letters from immigrants terrorized by the raids.

After reading their pleas, the pope reportedly had tears in his eyes. “The church cannot stay silent before injustice. You stand with me. And I stand with you,” Leo told the delegation.

He asked the U.S. hierarchy to speak out “strongly on this issue,” pressing them to finally act with one voice.

That papal nudge was pivotal.

In private discussions Tuesday night, the bishops labored for five hours to craft a message that would meet the moment — and meet the pope’s appeal for unity. Some initially worried about backlash from the White House or appearing “political.” But by Wednesday, those fears gave way to resolve.

The Vicar of Christ had asked for moral clarity, and the bishops were determined to deliver.

As one church insider observed, “Leo put the challenge to them. And they realized they couldn’t stay silent any longer – not when families are being torn apart.”

Indeed, in their statement the bishops explicitly echo Pope Leo’s consistent teaching that welcoming the stranger is as pro-life as defending the unborn.

Pope Leo’s influence could also be seen in the breadth of the statement: it balances a call for secure borders and law enforcement’s safety with an unequivocal demand for humane treatment and due process.

By affirming that human dignity and national security are not in conflict, the U.S. hierarchy sounded a note straight from Leo’s playbook — rejecting the false choice between protecting a nation and honoring the least among us.

For Pope Leo XIV, who has repeatedly clashed with Mr. Trump’s agenda, the bishops’ bold move is a vindication of his pastoral push. It signifies that the American Church he leads will not be cowed by political pressure when core Gospel values are at stake. In fact, this week’s events may mark a turning point.

“A new day is dawning,” one retired bishop told me after the vote. “We have found our backbone.”

Not Partisan – Christianity 101

The implications of the bishops’ stand will be felt far beyond the conference hall.

By denouncing the administration’s tactics as an affront to “God-given human dignity,” the U.S. Catholic leadership sent a clear message to 70 million American Catholics — including those in the pews who voted for Mr. Trump.

The Gospel of Jesus, they affirmed, leaves no room for rounding up immigrant families or sowing fear among the vulnerable. Defending migrants is not a matter of left or right, but of right and wrong.

The near-unanimous vote also puts Catholic politicians on notice.

Many high-profile members of the Trump administration (and Trump’s inner circle) are Catholics themselves.

The bishops’ statement implicitly calls them out, urging them to remember that their faith prioritizes mercy over partisan talking points.

It’s an extraordinary moment when virtually the entire American episcopate stands together to say enough — to declare that a policy crosses a moral line.

Cardinal Cupich noted that such unity sends a clear moral signal that the Church stands with migrant families and will not be silent in the face of injustice.

That solidarity is already emboldening local Church leaders: across the country, bishops have been accompanying immigrants to court, opening church sanctuaries, and organizing legal aid, but now they have the collective weight of the USCCB behind them.

Past confrontations — whether over war, economics, or even abortion policy — rarely saw the bishops speak so forcefully and with such unity.

The closest parallel might be the 1983 pastoral letter on nuclear arms or the early civil rights statements, but even those lacked the near-total consensus achieved here.

The bishops chose to describe the current deportation campaign as a direct assault on human dignity, effectively reading the administration’s policy as incompatible with Christian teaching. For a body that typically avoids overt political conflict, this was a dramatic evolution.

What made the difference? Moral clarity. Pope Leo’s relentless emphasis on the “least of these” has helped refocus the U.S. Church’s priorities. Many bishops who once hesitated to wade into immigration debates now see it as a pro-life issue of the highest order.

That shift in perspective made it possible for moderates and conservatives to join progressives in a common cause. In Baltimore, the bishops chose to stand together on the side of vulnerable families, reflecting Pope Leo’s teaching that “if she wants to be Christ’s Church, [the Church] must be a Church of the Beatitudes, one that makes room for the little ones.”

As the meeting closed, there was a sense that the Holy Spirit — and perhaps Leo XIV’s quiet hand — had steered the U.S. bishops to a new level of courage. It was a poignant reminder that behind the policy fights are real human lives. And it underscored why the Church felt compelled to act.

The bishops’ unified message in Baltimore will likely be remembered as a defining chapter of Pope Leo’s young papacy — a moment when the American Church stood up, nearly as one, to say no to fear and yes to dignity.

In doing so, they made history. More importantly, they lived out the Gospel mandate to welcome the stranger, even at the risk of political backlash. The true measure of this statement, however, will be whether it inspires action in parishes and communities.

The bishops have started the process. Their You Are Not Alone initiative, launched alongside the statement, aims to mobilize Catholics nationwide to accompany immigrant families in tangible ways.

In the end, the Church’s leaders have made their choice. They have chosen the Gospel over party. They have chosen solidarity over silence.

In one powerful voice, from Pope Leo in Rome to the pastors in Baltimore, they have declared: Enough. We will not abandon our migrant brothers and sisters.

This is the Catholic Church at its best — and it’s a moment that will reverberate for years to come.

Letters from Leo is open to anyone who wants to be informed and inspired by our pope — and to turn that inspiration into action that leaves America and the world more just, less cold, and more alive with hope.

If you want to support this mission, here’s how you can help:

• Subscribe as a paid member to receive exclusive posts about the life and formation of Pope Leo and help sustain this newsletter.

• Donate with a one-time gift to fuel this project’s mission.

• Share this post (and Letters from Leo) with a friend who might enjoy it.

Whether you give $0, $1, or $1,000, your presence here matters — no matter your faith or your politics.

Thank you for reading. I’ll see you on the road.